+91 76790 91881

Key Differences Between Public and Private Companies Explained

In the realm of corporate governance dictated by the Companies Act, 2013, (hereinafter referred to as “the Act”) the difference between public and private companies is pivotal for entrepreneurs, investors, and regulators. These classifications define ownership structures, regulatory compliance, and operational freedoms for businesses in India.

Private companies, known for their limited liability and fewer regulatory obligations, typically have restrictions on the number of shareholders they can have and are generally not permitted to sell shares to the public. This setup often appeals to smaller businesses and startups looking for operational flexibility and control over ownership. In contrast, public companies have a larger shareholder base and can sell shares to the public through stock exchanges. This broader ownership structure comes with more rigorous regulatory requirements, such as regular financial reporting, strict disclosure norms, and adherence to robust corporate governance standards aimed at safeguarding the interests of public investors.

Defining the Difference between Public and Private Companies

A public company, under Section 2(71) of the Act, is not a private company and has a minimum paid-up share capital of five lakh rupees or more. These companies can list their shares on stock exchanges, allowing public subscription and transferability of shares.

Conversely, a private company, as per Section 2(68) of the Act, restricts the transferability of its shares and limits its membership to 200 individuals, excluding One Person Companies (OPCs). Private companies have a more controlled ownership structure and cannot invite the public to subscribe to their shares.

Characteristics and Operational Variances

Public Company Characteristics:

  1. Legal Identity: Public companies are distinct legal entities separate from their shareholders, offering limited liability to shareholders proportional to their shareholding. The difference between public and private companies in this regard would be that private companies are typically closely held and managed by a smaller group of owners.
  2. Share Transferability: Shares of public companies are freely transferable, providing liquidity for investors. The difference between public and private companies in this regard would be that private companies restrict the transfer of shares, often requiring approval from existing shareholders or directors.
  3. Transparency and Disclosure: These companies must issue prospectuses and adhere to stringent disclosure norms. The difference between public and private companies in this regard would be that private companies have fewer regulatory obligations and do not issue prospectuses for raising funds from the public.
  4. Regulatory Compliance: Public companies are subject to extensive regulatory oversight, including the appointment of independent directors and regular disclosures to SEBI. The difference between public and private companies in this regard would be that private companies face less stringent scrutiny and governance requirements.

Private Company Characteristics:

  1. Legal Identity: Private companies also enjoy separate legal status but with restricted membership and share transferability. The difference between public and private companies in this regard would be that private companies typically limit their membership and have stricter controls over share transfers.
  2. Restricted Share Transfer: Transfer of shares requires adherence to procedures outlined in their Articles of Association. The difference between public and private companies in this regard would be that private companies often restrict share transfers to maintain control over ownership and management, whereas public companies allow freely transferable shares, providing liquidity for investors.
  3. Confidentiality: Private companies maintain confidentiality regarding their financial affairs. The difference between public and private companies in this regard would be that public companies have greater disclosure requirements, exposing more financial information to the public and regulatory authorities.
  4. Ownership and Control: Ownership is closely held, often by founders or strategic investors, facilitating quicker decision-making and operational control. The difference between public and private companies in this regard would be that private companies retain ownership within a smaller, closely-knit group, while public companies have a broader ownership base that may influence strategic decisions through voting rights and corporate governance structures.

Regulatory Compliance and Governance

Public Companies:

  1. Disclosure Requirements: Public companies must prepare and file annual financial statements, board reports, and disclose related party transactions. The difference between public and private companies in this regard would be that private companies have fewer mandatory disclosure requirements, often limiting disclosures to shareholders and regulatory authorities as required by law.
  2. Corporate Governance: They must appoint independent directors, establish board committees, and disclose executive compensation. The difference between public and private companies in this regard would be that private companies have more flexibility in structuring their governance, often with less formal board structures and fewer mandatory governance practices.
  3. Shareholder Meetings and Rights: Public companies must hold Annual General Meetings (AGMs) and Extraordinary General Meetings (EGMs). The difference between public and private companies in this regard would be that private companies have less stringent requirements for shareholder meetings and rights, typically holding meetings as per their Articles of Association and shareholder agreements.
  4. Regulatory Oversight: Continuous oversight by SEBI ensures compliance with listing rules and corporate governance norms. The difference between public and private companies in this regard would be that private companies face less regulatory scrutiny and oversight, focusing more on compliance with basic corporate laws under the Companies Act.

Private Companies:

  1. Limited Disclosure Requirements: Private companies prepare simpler financial statements and maintain confidentiality in board meetings and resolutions. The difference between public and private companies in this regard would be that public companies are required to disclose detailed financial statements and board reports to the public and regulatory bodies.
  2. Governance Flexibility: Private companies have more flexibility in board composition and shareholder meeting requirements. The difference between public and private companies in this regard would be that public companies must adhere to stricter corporate governance norms, including the appointment of independent directors and the establishment of board committees.
  3. Compliance Reporting: They must file annual returns and resolutions but face fewer reporting obligations compared to public companies. The difference between public and private companies in this regard would be that public companies are subject to extensive compliance reporting, including continuous disclosures to SEBI and adherence to listing rules and corporate governance standards.

Comparative Advantages and Disadvantages

Advantages of Public Companies:

  1. Access to Capital: They can raise funds through public offerings.
  2. Enhanced Transparency: Mandatory disclosures attract institutional investors and foster confidence.
  3. Shareholder Liquidity: Freely transferable shares enhance liquidity.

Disadvantages of Public Companies:

  1. Regulatory Burden: Compliance with extensive regulations can be costly.
  2. Loss of Control: Widely dispersed ownership limits control over strategic decisions.
  3. Market Scrutiny: Public scrutiny and stock price volatility can impact operations.

Advantages of Private Companies:

  1. Operational Flexibility: Reduced regulatory burden allows quicker decision-making.
  2. Controlled Ownership: Ownership concentration facilitates strategic control.
  3. Confidentiality: Limited disclosure protects sensitive information.

Disadvantages of Private Companies:

  1. Limited Access to Capital: Restricted to private funding sources.
  2. Restricted Exit Options: Limited market liquidity constrains shareholder exits.
  3. Governance Challenges: Lack of mandatory governance structures may impact sustainability and investor confidence.

Here is a tabulated form of the difference between public and private companies:

Basis for ComparisonPrivate Limited CompanyPublic Limited Company
MeaningNot listed on stock exchange; shares held privatelyListed on stock exchange; shares traded publicly
Minimum number of members27
Maximum number of members200 (except OPC)Unlimited
Minimum number of directors23
Articles of AssociationOwn articles requiredOwn or Table F can be adopted
Transfer of SharesRestricted as per Articles of AssociationFreely transferable on stock exchange
Public SubscriptionProhibitedAllowed (can issue prospectus or private placement)
Issue of prospectusProhibitedAllowed
Minimum amount of allotmentCan allot without minimum subscriptionCannot allot unless minimum subscription in prospectus
Commencement of BusinessCan start after incorporationRequires certificate of commencement after incorporation
Appointment of DirectorMultiple directors can be appointed by single resolutionDirectors must file consent and are subject to rotation
Filing of Consent to act as DirectorNot requiredRequired within 30 days of appointment
Retirement of Directors by rotationNot requiredRequired (2/3rd of directors must retire by rotation)
Place of Holding AGMAnywhereRegistered office or another specified location
Statutory MeetingOptionalCompulsory
Quorum2 members5 members (if ≤ 1000 members); 15 (1000-5000 members); 30 (> 5000 members)
ExemptionsEnjoys many privileges and exemptionsNo specific privileges or exemptions

Frequently Asked Questions

How many types of public companies are there?

There are two main types of public companies: listed and unlisted. Listed companies have shares traded on stock exchanges, while unlisted companies do not.

Which is better, a private or public company?

Public companies face stricter regulations, while private companies have more flexibility but less access to capital markets.

What is the difference between a private and public shareholder?

The shares of a public company are traded on a stock exchange, while a private company’s shares are not.

What is the difference between a public and private company board?

Public company governance is influenced by laws, regulations, and third parties, while private company boards have more freedom to choose their governance structures and processes.

Conclusion

The difference between public and private companies under Indian law encompasses governance, compliance, and operational implications. Public companies navigate stringent regulations for transparency and investor confidence, while private companies leverage confidentiality and control for strategic agility and growth. Understanding these distinctions is crucial for stakeholders in India’s corporate environment, ensuring informed decision-making and sustainable business practices.

In essence, whether opting for public visibility and capital access or preferring operational discretion and ownership control, adherence to regulatory frameworks remains paramount for fostering trust, transparency, and sustained growth in India’s corporate sector. InstaFiling can help companies navigate these regulatory frameworks with ease. Their expertise ensures accurate and timely compliance with all legal requirements, whether you’re operating as a public or private company.

Request A Callback





    You may Also Call Us At

    +91 76790 91881
    Scroll to Top